The Independence Pledge: A Stand Against Private Equity in Personal Injury Law
A legal consulting firm based in West Hartford has initiated a movement encouraging personal injury lawyers to commit publicly to avoiding private equity investment. Best Era, co-founded by attorney Ryan McKeen, has unveiled The Independence Pledge, which outlines ten key commitments for law firms prioritizing lawyer ownership.
The Pledge Explained
Firms that sign The Independence Pledge agree not to accept private equity funds directly or through management services organizations (MSOs). Recently, these MSOs have become a popular channel for private equity investors to acquire the operational side of personal injury firms nationwide.
“Most clients have no idea whether their firm is PE-backed,” stated McKeen. He asserts that it is crucial for clients to inquire about this aspect and for law firms to provide transparent answers.
Current Participation and Self-Reporting
As of now, 16 personal injury firms have endorsed the pledge, with two based in Connecticut: Etemi Law in Watertown and Baber Law in Middletown. Notably, these firms are self-reporting their commitment, meaning there is no legal enforcement of the pledge.
The Role of Management Services Organizations
Many states, including Connecticut, prohibit nonlawyers from owning law firms or sharing in legal fees. To navigate these regulations, investors frequently establish separate companies to manage a firm’s operations, covering marketing, intake, staffing, technology, and finances, while still letting the law firm maintain ownership on paper.
Uplift Investors, a private equity firm located in Connecticut, launched Orion Legal MSO in partnership with Louisiana’s Dudley DeBosier Injury Lawyers this January, extending its reach to personal injury firms in Kentucky, Georgia, Rhode Island, and Arkansas. The firm’s close associate in Rhode Island is Bottaro Injury Lawyers, which also practices in Massachusetts.
Arguments For and Against
Will Hausberg, managing partner at Uplift, emphasized that their model allows attorneys to focus more on client advocacy instead of administrative duties. He believes it enables smaller firms to stay competitive with their larger counterparts.
In a commentary for Fortune, he described personal injury firms as an ideal candidate for MSOs, given their financial model where they incur costs upfront and receive payment only after a case concludes.
In contrast, McKeen expressed concerns regarding this trend in the legal profession, which he views as “the most profound change in the practice of law in our lifetime.” He highlighted a conflict of interest where firms may prioritize financial returns over clients’ needs when private equity is involved.
Client Awareness and Transparency
With increasing financial pressures from rising advertising and staffing costs, McKeen asserts that many personal injury firms receive approaches from investors. He noted that typical auto insurance policy caps have not increased, heightening the need for law firms to be financially agile.
The Independence Pledge also provides clients with five questions to ask potential lawyers before hiring them, including inquiries about the firm’s ownership and whether an external company oversees its operations.
McKeen pointed out that it is often challenging for clients to discern whether a firm is partnered with an MSO due to branding and naming conventions remaining unchanged. “There are no rules that I know of that require disclosure,” he stated.
Broader Trends in Connecticut
This call for transparency comes amid a trend where private equity buyers have been acquiring various businesses in Connecticut, including notable firms such as Hartford’s Tecton Architects and Koma Precision in East Windsor.
