Key Takeaways
- Strategy (MSTR) stock has experienced a 27% decline in 2026, with losses primarily occurring post-September.
- MSCI’s decision to remove Strategy from its indexes coincides with increased expenditures on preferred stock, complicating its ability to sell shares at a premium for bitcoin acquisitions.
- Coinbase (COIN) is also seeing a downward trend, having fallen 44% this year, but its challenges are separate from those faced by Strategy.
- Currently valued at 0.9 times book value, the stock appears undervalued historically, yet remains largely stagnant until new weekly filings indicate renewed bitcoin purchases.
In 2026, Strategy (MSTR) stock has seen a decrease of 27%, with all declines occurring since the close of September. Following a crash in June and a recovery in the third quarter, where it regained some ground, Strategy plunged after MSCI announced its removal from indices, leading to a shift in financial priorities towards preferred stock instead of bitcoin purchases.
The broader crypto landscape is feeling the strain as well, with Coinbase (COIN) reporting a 44% decline this year. Nonetheless, the issues affecting Strategy are more tied to its operational decisions and index removals, adversely impacting its bitcoin acquisition strategy.
June Crash, Summer Recovery, and MSCI’s Impact
Bitcoin’s value dropped to around $58,700 by the end of June. Strategy’s preferred shares (STRC), which raised approximately $7.5 billion by late July, were trading in the $70s—well below their $100 par value. However, the cryptocurrency market rebounded, resulting in a 76% increase in Strategy’s stock during the third quarter, compared to a 43% rise in bitcoin during the same period.
The downward trajectory commenced on October 15 when MSCI implemented its screening for non-operating firms, causing a nearly 10% drop in stock on October 16. By October 26, Strategy disclosed that it had not purchased any bitcoin in the preceding week and had allocated $204.9 million towards STRC buybacks. Its third-quarter report indicated a negative BTC Yield of 3.7% for the year up to October 25, coinciding with the announcement of the resignation of CFO Andrew Kang. MSCI confirmed that Strategy would be deleted from its indices effective November 30, leading to another 6.5% stock drop, shortly followed by bitcoin falling below $70,000, marking a decline from the average purchase price of $75,456 per coin held by Strategy.
TIKR currently tracks 16 analysts for Strategy’s stock. A question remains: how many analysts are recommending a “Buy”?
The Erosion of Strategy’s Premium
Strategy generates approximately $500 million annually from its software business, with forecasts showing little variation in revenue through 2028. Thus, the stock’s performance is closely linked to bitcoin prices and the strategy employed to finance these acquisitions. In 2026 alone, it raised an impressive $21.23 billion, primarily through common stock sales.
Management indicated that to enhance bitcoin per share, sales of new shares must occur at prices exceeding the bitcoin value inherent in each share. The break-even point for this valuation stood at roughly 1.22 times the market-adjusted net asset value (mNAV).
Currently, this premium has vanished, as shares trade at about 0.9 times book value, a stark contrast to its five-year average of 3.8 times.
Preferred dividends have surged to $419.6 million in the latest quarter, triple the amount from the previous year. During a week leading up to November 8, Strategy sold $283.8 million in new shares, allocating $188.3 million towards buybacks and only $81.9 million towards bitcoin purchases. Additionally, its cash reserves for dividends and interest fell to $4.77 billion.
According to Strategy’s estimates, MSCI-tracking funds hold roughly 13 million shares, accounting for 3.1% of the outstanding stock. While this forced selling is manageable, the primary impact lies in the loss of a stable buyer as the company continues to offload shares. In contrast, Coinbase, which operates an exchange, is not burdened by these issues.
Upcoming Challenges: November 30 as a Critical Milestone
Analysts maintain an average target price of around $233 for Strategy stock, although Monness recently revised its target down to $100 from $121.03 while keeping a Hold rating. Executive Chairman Michael Saylor expressed optimism in the third-quarter release, noting, “We’re at the beginning of the next bitcoin bull market.”
An increase in bitcoin prices would significantly influence Strategy’s stock performance more than any other variable. However, without a premium to speak of, each newly issued share dilutes bitcoin per share value, and recent funding has siphoned more towards STRC buybacks than bitcoin investments. Hence, the stock is severely stagnated until these dynamics change.
The upcoming weekly filings post-November 30 will reveal whether Strategy is resuming bitcoin purchases. Additionally, the fourth quarter earnings report is expected in early February, while holders of approximately $1 billion in convertible notes can start requesting cash redemptions starting September 2027.
Evaluating the Worth of Strategy Stock
TIKR provides an efficient tool for forecasting potential stock prices in mere minutes. Users can input their assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model to determine the estimated value of Strategy based on current Wall Street consensus or tailor parameters to reflect personal assessments of the business.
Value Strategy for free using TIKR’s innovative tools.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended as specific investment or financial advice and do not serve as recommendations to buy or sell stocks. The content is generated based on investment data and analyst estimates available on TIKR Terminal. This analysis may not encompass recent company developments or important updates. TIKR maintains no investment positions in any of the stocks discussed. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!
