Controversy Erupts Over Chabad Rabbi’s Letter on Arab Political Parties
By Anash.org reporter
Background of the Dispute
In recent developments within Israeli politics, MK Michal Rozin of the left-wing “Democrats” party has called for a criminal investigation into Harav Gedalia Axelrod, a well-respected Chabad rabbi and former Av Beis Din of Chaifa. This call stems from a halachic ruling issued by Harav Axelrod regarding the potential formation of an Israeli government that might involve support from Arab political factions.
Harav Axelrod’s Halachic Ruling
In a letter released earlier this week, Harav Axelrod expressed strong opposition to the establishment of a government with backing from Arab parties. He warned that politicians facilitating such coalitions would fall into a halachic category whereby their actions might endanger the lives of others. He further stated that lawmakers who choose to abstain from voting on such coalitions would also bear responsibility for endangering Jewish lives.
Political Responses
In response to Harav Axelrod’s letter, MK Rozin expressed grave concerns on the social media platform X, asserting that the rabbi’s remarks crossed boundaries from religious expression into what she deemed criminal incitement. She compared the current rhetoric to the environment leading up to the assassination of former Israeli Prime Minister Yitzchak Rabin in 1995, emphasizing the danger posed by inflammatory language towards political leaders.
These statements occur in a politically charged context, particularly as Democrats chairman Yair Golan has been vocal in advocating for coalition governments that include Arab parties, arguing against what he terms a “racist separation” in voting practices.
Calls for Investigation
The controversy intensified further when the Center for Victims of Racism lodged an urgent complaint with the Israeli authorities, including the Israel Police, Attorney General, and State Attorney’s Office. They demanded an investigation into what they characterized as potential offenses related to incitement to violence, solicitation of murder, and incitement to racism.
Civil Rights Perspective
The calls for an investigation have not gone unchallenged. Shai Glick, director of the Israeli civil rights group B’Tsalmo, criticized the left-wing politicians and organizations for allegedly attempting to silence rabbinical voices through the threat of prosecution. Glick stated, “The Knesset has barely begun, and the silencing has already started,” advocating for the dismissal of the complaint and asserting that religious leaders should not face criminal repercussions for expressing their halachic views.
Chabad’s Official Stance
In light of the backlash, Rabbi Shimi Segal, a spokesperson for Chabad, emphasized that Harav Axelrod’s opinions do not reflect the official positions of Chabad. He clarified, “Chabad’s official halachic positions are determined exclusively by the Chabad Rabbinical Court, in accordance with the Rebbe’s instructions.” Notably, he pointed out that Harav Axelrod is not a member of the court and his statements should be viewed strictly as his personal views.
